Statement: Racism and Institutionalised Discrimination in the Israeli COVID-19 Vaccine

Statement: Racism and Institutionalised Discrimination in the Israeli COVID-19 Vaccine

[The following joint statement, entitled, “Racism and Institutionalized Discrimination in the Roll-Out of the COVID-19 Vaccine,” was issued on Jan. 18, 2021 by the Palestinian NGOs Network (PNGO), the Palestinian Human Rights Organizations Council (PHROC), and the Palestinian National Institute for NGOs (PNIN).  The Middle East Council of Churches, a partner of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) and United Church of Christ), is among the signatories.]

The Palestinian NGOs Network (PNGO) and the Palestinian Human Rights Organizations Council (PHROC) and the Palestinian National Institute for NGOs (PNIN) are concerned that since commencing the roll out of a vaccine against COVID-19 in December 2020, the Israeli occupying authorities have implemented its vaccine policy in a discriminatory, unlawful, and racist manner by completely disregarding its obligations to Palestinian healthcare.

Throughout the Occupied Palestinian Territory (OPT), apart from East Jerusalem, Israeli occupying authorities have reserved access to the vaccine to the unlawfully transferred in settler population of Jewish Israelis in illegal settlements, and denied the vaccine to the Palestinian population. According to data collected by the University of Oxford, around 1.99 million Israelis, Palestinian citizens of Israel, and Palestinian from occupied East Jerusalem had been vaccinated by 13 January 2021. According to the State of Palestine’s Negotiation Affairs Department, as of 9 January 2021, there were over 165,000 active cases in the occupied State of Palestine, including in East Jerusalem.[1]  As of 13 January, 1814 Palestinians in the OPT lost their lives to COVID-19.

In March 2020, the Chairpersons of the ten United Nations (UN) Human Rights Treaty Bodies issued a joint statement calling on States parties “to adopt measures to protect the rights to life and health, and to ensure access to health care to all who need it, without discrimination”.[2] Representing the Chairpersons’, Hilary Gbedemah, Chair of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women, warned against States exploiting the COVID-19 pandemic to violate human rights and affirmed that “States must take active steps to ensure a sense of solidarity prevails, including through protection against racism and xenophobia or the growth of unbridled nationalism”.

As affirmed by the Committee on the Elimination for Racial Discrimination (CERD) in August 2020, States have international law obligations to “ensure, in their own actions as well as through international cooperation, that the development of vaccines as well as access to an eventual vaccine against COVID-19 occur in a non-discriminatory manner, taking into account the situation and needs of groups which are marginalized and subjected to discrimination”.[3]

Israel’s Obligations to Distribute Vaccine to all Palestinians under its Control

Israel, as Occupying Power of the Palestinian territory, i.e. the West Bank, including East Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip, has clear obligations to ensure the protection and respect of the right to health of the protected population. In particular, Article 55(1) of the Fourth Geneva Convention establishes Israel’s duty, as Occupying Power, to ensure the provision of medical supplies to the civilian population in the OPT to the fullest extent of the means available to it. 

Further, Article 14(1) of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, reflective of customary international humanitarian law, provides that the Occupying Power has the duty to ensure that the medical needs of the civilian population continue to be satisfied, while Article 69(1) requires the Occupying Power to ensure, without adverse distinction, the provision of supplies essential to the survival of the civilian population. 

These critical provisions are to be read in conjunction with Article 56 of the Fourth Geneva Convention, which provides that: “To the fullest extent of the means available to it, the Occupying Power has the duty of ensuring and maintaining, with the co-operation of national and local authorities, the medical and hospital establishments and services, public health and hygiene in the occupied territory, with particular reference to the adoption and application of the prophylactic and preventive measures necessary to combat the spread of contagious diseases and epidemics.”

Since the outbreak of COVID-19, Israel has rejected these responsibilities, by failing to protect Palestinian workers in Israel, Palestinian prisoners and detainees in Israeli detention centers, denying Palestinians in the Gaza Strip access to healthcare, and systematically neglecting the healthcare in occupied East Jerusalem. While some commentary has sought to suggest that Israel’s obligations as an occupying power are in some way diluted or excused by the terms of the Oslo Accords, we reiterate that Article 8 of the Fourth Geneva Convention asserts that ‘protected persons may in no circumstances renounce in part or in entirety the rights secured to them by the present Convention’, and Article 47 of the aforementioned Convention further asserts that:

“Protected persons who are in occupied territory shall not be deprived, in any case or in any manner whatsoever, of the benefits of the present Convention by any change introduced, as the result of the occupation of a territory, into the institutions or government of the said territory, nor by any agreement concluded between the authorities of the occupied territories and the Occupying Power, nor by any annexation by the latter of the whole or part of the occupied territory.”
The Palestinian healthcare system in the OPT has suffered decades of deliberate neglect, de-development, and fragmentation, which hamper an effective COVID-19 response. Longstanding Israeli practices of closures of Palestinian cities, villages, and towns, and continuous movement and access restrictions are a staple of Israel’s prolonged military occupation, undermining the right of Palestinians to access available healthcare and to develop their own healthcare system. In its 2018 report on the right to health in Palestine, the World Health Organization (WHO) warned that the health system in the OPT is fragmented and fragile and highlighted the precariousness of the situation in the Gaza Strip, noting that the “ongoing blockade and successive conflicts have had a devastating impact on underlying factors that contribute to health and well-being”. Under international human rights law, Palestinians on both sides of the Green Line are entitled to respect, protection, and fulfilment of their right to the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health, as enshrined in Article 12(1) of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). The Committee for Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR) has stressed that: “In all circumstances, in times of peace and during conflict, States have an obligation to maintain a functioning health-care system. They must maintain essential primary health care… as well as provide essential drugs, while respecting the principles of non-discrimination and equitable access. States must also design and implement public health strategies.”[4]

CESCR has further affirmed that, in line with their core obligations to fulfill economic, social, and cultural rights, States must “take measures to prevent, treat and control epidemic and endemic diseases”.[5] In its November 2019 Concluding Observations on Israel, CESCR expressed its deep concern: “about the severe impact of the policies adopted by the State party relating to the Occupied Palestinian Territory, namely the closure policy and the related permit regime regarding the Gaza Strip and the occupation and settlement policy in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, on the enjoyment of Covenant rights by people living there, including the rights to work, food, water and sanitation, health and education, and to their cultural rights”.[6]

Vaccine Roll-Out Exposes Israel’s Inhumane Acts of Apartheid

That the fragmentation of Palestinians into segregated administrative groupings, separated from each other, to maintain Israel’s settler colonial expansion constituting apartheid, has been vividly evidenced through the racist and structurally violent method by which Israel has restricted access to the vaccine to specific Palestinian groups, other than those Palestinians in occupied East Jerusalem.

In December 2019, the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) recalled its General Recommendation No. 19 (1995) concerning the prevention, prohibition and eradication of all policies and practices of racial segregation and apartheid, and urged Israel “to eradicate all forms of segregation between Jewish and non-Jewish communities and any such policies or practices which severely and disproportionately affect the Palestinian population in Israel proper and in the Occupied Palestinian Territory”.[7]

While the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights has urged “authorities in countries affected by COVID-19 to take all necessary steps to address incidents of xenophobia or stigmatization”, the very basis of Israel’s prolonged military occupation continues to be one of structural racism and the denial of Palestinians’ inalienable rights. Amnesty International has observed that “Israel’s COVID-19 vaccine program highlights the institutionalized discrimination that defines the Israeli government’s policy towards Palestinians. While Israel celebrates a record-setting vaccination drive, millions of Palestinians living under Israeli control in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip will receive no vaccine or have to wait much longer – there could hardly be a better illustration of how Israeli lives are valued above Palestinian ones”.

States COVID-19 Human Rights Obligations 

In its August 2020 Statement on the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic and its implications under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, CERD observed that groups that are subject to racial discrimination are “disproportionally affected by the overall negative impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on health services in general, with health issues not directly related to the COVID-19 disease being left unattended. The pandemic thereby exposes and further deepens structural inequalities affecting vulnerable groups protected under the Convention, based on entrenched structures and practices of discrimination and exclusion”.[8]

CERD stressed that States “must protect against and mitigate the impact of the pandemic on individuals and groups subject to structural discrimination and disadvantage”[9] and emphasised that “States have an obligation to ensure equal access to healthcare services, including testing, medicine and medical procedures, and to eliminate discriminatory practices against groups and minorities protected under the Convention”.[10]

Significantly, CERD emphasized the obligations of States under the Convention to “ensure, in their own actions as well as through international cooperation, that the development of vaccines as well as access to an eventual vaccine against COVID-19 occur in a non-discriminatory manner, taking into account the situation and needs of groups which are marginalized and subjected to discrimination”.[11]

In its on-going roll-out of COVID-19 vaccinations, Israel is directly violating its humanitarian and human rights law obligations by denying lifesaving vaccines to Palestinians as part of its policy of maintaining its apartheid regime of institutionalized domination. This policy has revealed in a direct and clear manner how the system of apartheid operates. Rather than typically spurious claims of security or self-defense being relied upon to seek to explain away or justify the racist treatment and dispossession of Palestinians through colonial violence, Israel is signalling to the world that its rejection of international law is premised on racial, rather than security grounds. The Palestinian Human Rights Organizations Council, the Palestinian NGOs Network, and the Palestinian National Institute for NGOs call on:

  1. Israel to immediately comply with its IHL and IHRL obligations to the protected occupied population in the Gaza Strip and West Bank, including East Jerusalem and ensure the non-discriminatory provision of vaccines to all persons in the territory under its control;

  2. Israel to ensure the provision of life saving COVID-19 vaccinations to Palestinian prisoners and detainees incarcerated in Israeli prisons and detention centers;

  3. Third States to respect and ensure respect for the Geneva Conventions, including by ensuring that Israel, the Occupying Power, supplies lifesaving COVID-19 vaccinations to the Palestinian Authority for distribution to the protected occupied Palestinian population;

  4. Pfizer, as a leading international pharmaceutical company, to comply with its responsibilities under the UNGPs and to act with due diligence to ensure that its supply of vaccines is not used in the service of illegal settlement activity or to entrench apartheid policies and practices, and to seek assurances that its vaccine is not intended for use in a discriminatory, racist and xenophobic manner;

  5. The international community to hold Israel to account for denial of health care amounting to the wilful causing of great suffering and injury to the health of the Palestinian population, where this amounts to grave breaches of the Fourth Geneva Convention; and 

  6. The Palestinian Authority to enhance its active role in ensuring the protection of Palestinian protected population during a global pandemic, including by continuously reminding Israel of its legal obligations, as Occupying Power, and urging the international community to take effective measures to halt Israel’s discriminatory policies and practices. 

** This statement contains an updated list of signatories and was initially published by Al-Haq on 14 January 2021.
 
Joining organizations:
Palestinian Non-Governmental Organizations Network (PNGO), including:

  1. Agriculture & Environment Development Society

  2. Aisha Association for Woman & Child Protection 

  3. Al Foukhary Association for Development and Culture

  4. Al Sattar Garbee Association for Developing Countryside and Farmer 

  5. Alahleya Society for Development of Palm and Dates

  6. Alanqaa Association for Community Development 

  7. Al-Ataa Society for Development 

  8. Al-Atta Charitable Society 

  9. Al-Awda Center for Childhood and the Youth 

  10. Almanal Society for Developing the Rural Women 

  11. Alrowwad Cultural and Arts Society 

  12. Alsahel Association for Development

  13. Altaghreed Association for Culture and Development 

  14. Al-Tawasol Forum Society  

  15. Al-Wefaq Association for Relief and Development 

  16. Applied Research Institute-Jerusalem (ARIJ) 

  17. Arab Center for Agricultural Development (ACAD)

  18. Arab Women Union Society 

  19. Asala for Credit and Development 

  20. Atfaluna Society for Deaf Children 

  21. Bait AL Mostuqbal Association 

  22. Baitona For Community Development 

  23. Balsam Association for Community Rehabilitation 

  24. Beesan Benevolent Association 

  25. Bisan Center-Research and Development Studies in Palestine

  26. Central Blood Bank Society 

  27. Community Media Center 

  28. Disability Representative Body Network 

  29. Dr. Haider Abdel Shafi Center 

  30. Early Childhood Resource Center (ECRC)

  31. El Amal Rehabilitation Society–Rafah 

  32. El Wafaa Charitable Society  

  33. ElWedad Society for Community Rehabilitation 

  34. Fajr Association for Relief and Development 

  35. Gaza community Mental Health program

  36. Gaza Culture & Development Group

  37. Hanan for Culture and Social Development Association

  38. Health Work Committee  

  39. Human Rights & Democracy Media Center “Shams”  

  40. Human Rights & Rehabilitation Center (TRC)

  41. Jabalia Rehabilitation Society 

  42. Khalil Sakakini Cultural Center 

  43. Khuza’a Permaculture Center Association 

  44. Land Research Union 

  45. Local Association for Social Services 

  46. Ma’an Development Center 

  47. Middle East Council of Churches 

  48. Mother’s School Society 

  49. National Society for Rehabilitation 

  50. Palestine Amputee Football Association 

  51. Palestinian Agricultural Development Association 

  52. Palestinian Al-Nakheel Association for progress and development  

  53. Palestinian Association for Development and Construction (PADR)

  54. Palestinian Center for Development & Media Freedoms 

  55. Palestinian Charity Society  

  56. Palestinian Counseling Center 

  57. Palestinian Family Planning & Protection Association 

  58. Palestinian Farmers Association 

  59. Palestinian Hydrology Group 

  60. Palestinian Medical Relief Society 

  61. Palestinian Right and Justice Association 

  62. Palestinian Youth Union 

  63. Psycho-Social Counseling Center for Women

  64. Public Aid Society

  65. Ramallah Center for Human Rights Studies

  66. Red Crescent Society for Gaza Strip

  67. Sareyyet Ramallah

  68. Social Development Forum

  69. Society of Remedial Education center

  70. Stars of Hope Society (SHS)

  71. Tamer Institute for Community Education

  72. Teacher Creativity Center

  73. Thalasemia Patients Friends Society Palestine

  74. The Assembly Benevolent of Operation

  75. The Civil Commission for the Independence of the Judiciary and the Rule of Law

  76. The Culture and Free Thought Association

  77. The Democracy and Workers’ Rights Center/ Gaza

  78. The Eastearn Association for Agriculture

  79. The National Centre for Community Rehabilitation (NCCR)

  80. The National Society for Democracy and Law

  81. The Palestinian Center for Organic Agriculture

  82. The Palestinian Hydrology Group/Gaza

  83. The Palestinian Institute for Communication and Development

  84. The Palestinian Working Women Society for Development

  85. The Society of Women Graduates in Gaza Strip

  86. Union of Agricultural Work Committees

  87. Union of Health Care Committees

  88. Union of Palestinian Medical Relief Committees-Gaza

  89. Union of Palestinians Women’s Committees

  90. Wassel Center for Youth Development

  91. Women’s Studies Centre

  92. Zakher Association for Capacity Development of Palestinian Women 

Palestinian Human Rights Organizations Council (PHROC), comprising of:

  1. Addameer Prisoner Support and Human Rights Association

  2. Al Mezan Center for Human Rights

  3. Aldameer Association for Human Rights

  4. Al-Haq – Law in the Service of Man

  5. Defense for Children International (DCI) – Palestine

  6. Hurryyat – Center for Defense of Liberties and Civil Rights

  7. Jerusalem Legal Aid and Human Rights Center (JLAC)

  8. Muwatin Institute for Democracy and Human Rights – Observer

  9. Palestinian Centre for Human Rights (PCHR)

  10. Ramallah Center for Human Rights Studies (RCHRS)

  11. The Independent Commission for Human Rights (Ombudsman Office) – Observer

The Palestinian National Institute for NGOs (PNIN), including (62 NNGO)

[1] PLO NAD, “COVID-19 Vaccines and Israel’s Obligations as an Occupying Power,” 11 January 2021.

[2] UN Human Rights Treaty Bodies call for human rights approach in fighting COVID-19, 24 March 2020.

[3]Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, “Statement 3 (2020): Prevention of Racial Discrimination, Including Early Warning and Urgent Action Procedures. Statement on the Coronavirus (COVID-19) Pandemic and its Implications Under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination,” 7 August 2020.para. 5.

[4] ICRC, “Factsheet: Respecting and Protecting Health Care in Armed Conflicts and in Situations Not Covered by International Humanitarian Law,” page 3. 

[5] UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR), General Comment No. 14: The Right to the Highest Attainable Standard of Health (Art. 12 of the Covenant), 11 August 2000, E/C.12/2000/4. para. 44. 

[6] UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR), UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Concluding Observations on the fourth Periodic Report of Israel, 12 November 2019, E/C.12/ISR/CO/4. para.10. 

[7] CERD Concluding observations on the combined seventeenth to nineteenth reports of Israel, 12 December 2019, CERD/C/ISR/CO/17-19, para 23.

[8]Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, “Statement 3 (2020): Prevention of Racial Discrimination, Including Early Warning and Urgent Action Procedures. Statement on the Coronavirus (COVID-19) Pandemic and its Implications Under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination,” 7 August 2020. 

[9]Ibid. para. 4.

[10]Ibid. para. 4.a.

[11]Ibid. para. 5.